Zera Yacob · Philosophy
The method of Ethiopia’s great 17th-century philosopher: <em>hatata</em> means inquiry, and Zera Yacob made reason examine every received claim. Alone in a cave, he reasoned his way to a criterion of truth in what scholars have called an Ethiopian ‘cogito’ moment.
First, clear up a confusion of names. This lesson is not about the famous 15th-century Emperor Zara Yaqob (who reigned from 1434 to 1468), but about the philosopher Zera Yacob (1599 to 1692), born to a farmer’s family near Aksum. In the 1620s the Ethiopian emperor Susenyos, persuaded by Jesuit missionaries, converted to Roman Catholicism and made it the state faith, and persecution of dissenters followed. Zera Yacob, a teacher who had said that no one religion could claim to be the single truth, was denounced to the king. He fled south by night, carrying only a little gold and the Book of Psalms, and came upon a beautiful cave at the foot of a valley near the Tekeze River. There he lived as a hermit for two years, until the king’s death in 1632, praying and thinking - and there he worked out a new philosophy built not on authority but on inquiry. He called that inquiry hatata.
A pious objector would say that to question the faith is to sin against God. Zera Yacob turned this exactly around. God, he reasoned, is the Creator who placed the light of intelligence in the human heart precisely so that we could tell truth from falsehood and good from evil. If reason is God’s own gift, then using it honestly cannot offend the Giver; on the contrary, to refuse to think, and to believe blindly whatever people happen to have taught you, is to insult the intelligence God entrusted to you. Faith and reason, on his account, flow from the same source, so there can be no real war between them. What passes for a conflict is really a conflict between reason and the human additions that men have wrapped around religion. This is why, for Zera Yacob, prayer and inquiry belonged together: to think hard and honestly in the cave was itself a way of drawing near to the Creator who made him able to think.
Later readers have noticed a striking parallel between the cave meditation and the method of René Descartes, writing in Europe at the very same time. Both men, dissatisfied with inherited opinion, withdrew into solitude, doubted what they had merely been taught, and tried to rebuild knowledge from the ground up, starting from what a single reasoning mind could establish for itself. Descartes began from the certainty of his own thinking existence; Zera Yacob began from his own existence and reasoned outward to a Creator and to a standard of truth. Neither borrowed from the other - they never met and never read each other - which makes the convergence all the more remarkable. Some scholars therefore speak of an ‘Ethiopian cogito’ and call Zera Yacob a founder of modern rationalist philosophy in his own right. The point is not that he copied Europe, but that a African thinker, unaided, arrived at the characteristic modern gesture: make the individual’s own reason, not tradition, the starting place of knowledge.
This is the opening of the lesson. The rest — the dialogue, the primary source, and the recall — is in the app.
You learned that hatata means inquiry or investigation, that Zera Yacob developed his rationalist method as a hermit in a cave near the Tekeze River during the persecutions under Emperor Susenyos, and that he held reason and faith to come alike from the Creator. Explain the method and why he thought inquiry cannot off…
Leads to Rene Descartes.
Begin this lesson →epoché — a humanities education that remembers you.